Tez Türü: Doktora
Tezin Yürütüldüğü Kurum: University of London-Queen Mary and Westfield College, İngiltere
Tez Danışmanı: Prof Dr Dylan Morrissey
Tezin Onay Tarihi: 2022
Tezin Dili: İngilizce
Desteklendiği Program: Diğer
Özet:
Introduction
Rotator Cuff (RC) tendinopathy is common with a poor recovery rate and unclear prognosis. Previous cohort studies have investigated improvement but none have considered a wide range of bio-psycho-social factors as predictors of recovery. In particular, the relationship between scapular dyskinesis (ScDys) and shoulder pain presentation and prognosis remains unclear.
Aims
The primary aim was to build clinically applicable model to explain RC tendinopathy recovery. The secondary aim was to identify factors associated with severity and how RC tendinopathy differs from other shoulder problems. Preparatory aims included developing scapular dyskinesis (ScDys) assessments and a novel graded loaded challenge procedure, and investigating relationship between scapular kinematics and condition severity. The impact of success would be improved clinical tools to assess and consider prognosis for RC tendinopathy.
Methods
The project includes 5 linked studies. A systematic review was conducted to explore the reliability, validity and feasibility of clinical ScDys measurement with an evidence gap map including quality assessment, risk of bias appraisal, meta-analysis and level of evidence being constructed. A feasibility study was carried out to evaluate the validity, reliability, and feasibility of measures- including novel remote ScDys assessment and graded loaded challenge procedures. These were used in the case-control study, in which regression analyses were conducted to identify what bio-psycho-social variables, alone and in combination, were associated with RC tendinopathy presence and distinguish RC tendinopathy from other shoulder problems. In the fourth, regression and validity analyses were implemented to examine the association between scapular kinematics and condition severity and the criterion validity of the remote ScDys assessment, respectively. The culmination was a cohort study, in which cox regression was conducted to build a multi-variable model determining outcome predictors.
Results
The systematic review identified many clinical ScDys examination methods but none with adequate validity, reliability and feasibility. The feasibility study showed that the cohort study measures were valid, reliable, and feasible for remote assessment. The developed remote ScDys assessment method was found to be valid, reliable and apparently feasible. However, feasibility was not confirmed in the subsequent cohort study.
In the case-control study; previous shoulder injury, worse pain with activity, high self-efficacy and higher activity levels partially distinguished RC tendinopathy (n= 82) from other shoulder problems (n=54) even though the groups had comparable overall pain and functional compromise. The model demonstrated acceptable accuracy (AUC=0.77) with 76% specificity and 74% sensitivity. Lower quality of life, worse night pain, worse unilateral morning stiffness, higher body mass index, higher fear avoidance and higher catastrophising explained 68% of the variance in RC tendinopathy severity (n=82, R2=0.68). The graded loaded challenge was shown to be a promising objective functional test, and the remote ScDys criterion validity was acceptable (ICC2,k_absolute=0.55–0.93).
In the cohort study, 73 people with RC tendinopathy provided 15,189 days total analysis time at risk (208±129 days per person). The recovery rate was 47% occurring mainly around the 7 month follow-up. The final model (Chi-square= 9.99 and p= 0.007), including activity (Hazard ratio (95%) = 2.23 (1.08–4.61)) level and general health status (Hazard ratio (95%) = 1.03 (1.01–1.05)), partially predicted RC tendinopathy recovery, demonstrating moderate model performance and good internal validation (optimism-corrected Harrell's C=0.66, calibration slope=0.99).
Conclusion and Impact
Remote examination and self-reported factors could be useful to augment face-to-face examination and give information about people with RC tendinopathy and its severity. A promising remote ScDys method and graded loaded challenge have been developed and further merit clinical evaluation. The final model included two self-reported outcome predictors such as a social (activity level) and a psychological (general health status). Both factors could be important constructs to measure at initial assessment as they partially predicted recovery and were easily collected. Our explanatory models should improve clinicians’ understanding of RC tendinopathy profile and prognosis, and practice change may be confidently recommended after external model validation.